Book review magazines around the net have been abuzz with the news that Dan Brown has recently released the cover artwork for his follow up to 'The Da Vinci Code' which is to be titled 'The Lost Symbol.' I'm sure it will be one of the biggest book releases in the history of ever. More copies sold than the bible. And, curiously enough, armchair intellectuals will congratulate themselves and Dan Brown for cracking open another mystery of religion and clandestine organizations, as well as being able to take those 'Bibley-types' down a peg. What a wonderful thing it is. Surely, there will be numerous companions and television specials deciphering all the strange coincidences and purported facts Dan Brown will enlighten us with. All of this is well and fine.
But it all makes me very very sad.
Conspiracy theory is a subject dear to my heart. I would never at any time degrade myself by proclaiming to be a 'conspiracy theorist.' I'll leave such titles to the uncreative and small of mind. A conspiracy theory is a jumble of information some of which may or may not be correct. In many cases it is a revision of history as we know it, or an ongoing plot that has yet to unfurl itself. But mainly, they are merely stories. That is all. My favorite conspiracy theories walk a tightrope between fact and fiction, providing me with enough points of reference that I may check them at some point and perhaps see a small grain of truth. Most of the time I get tiny snippets of information that inhabit the excluded middle; a place where Aristotelian logic dare not tread. An artful conspiracy theory is one that sounds true, has a bit of whimsy to it, perhaps a wink, but probably isn't true in any way. This doesn't exist anymore and I blame three current figures for killing it.
The first is
Dan Brown. He has provided some intellectual element to conspiracy theory. His stories are enjoyed by middle aged people of moderate intelligent who don't read on a regular basis, as well as people stuck at airports. His well crafted books read like they were written by a quiet librarian who loved Indiana Jones. I have no quarrel with his writing, just the fact that atheists and fundamental materialists seem to take his Christianity-baiting at some sort of value. He knows he's writing crap, but many people buy it hook and sinker. Problem is, there's no line. Most of 'The Da Vinci' code was nicked from another book published in the early eighties, called '
Holy Blood, Holy Grail' which for my money is a brilliant work of artful conspiracy theory. Funny thing is, more people bought the theory when Dan Brown presented it, than when Michael Baigent, Richard Leigh, and Henry Lincoln published it. Funny how that works.
The second murderer is a fellow called
David Icke, who was once so bold that he published a book called
'The Biggest Secret: The Book that Will Change the World.' In it, he solved the puzzle as to why the world is so fucked up. It just so happens to be because there is an
Illuminati controlling everything. No big change here from numerous conspiracy theories of the past two hundred and fifty years, right? Well, this Illuminati is actually a race of alien reptiles that has crossbred with humans for centuries. Honestly, he totally believes this and people believe him as well. The other day a friend of mine was rambling on and on how she had done hours of research that day on it, and that it looks to be so. She told me about the reptile children in the Philippines and pictures of George W. Bush looking fairly reptilian. Infuriating to no end.
The last perpetrator is a right-wing loudmouth called
Alex Jones. At first I found him to be somewhat amusing. Bat-shit crazy, but still amusing. He has over the last ten years gained considerable acclaim for some reason. His shtick is that there is a group of people, an Illuminati if you will, that want to make the entire
planet into a prison and create a New World Order. Nothing freaks out the right-wing like having a single government ruling the world. He has a radio show and can also be found going to the
Bilderberg Group meetings and screaming at them with a megaphone. You show them.
There was a time in which conspiracy theory was not merely about pointing a finger at some invisible force, and that some of those involved were seriously trying to find out what was going on. At the beginning of the John F. Kennedy craze, there were individuals who were considered lunatics at the time, earnestly trying to chip away at what was perhaps a genuine conspiracy. They didn't have a grand theory to begin with, they were just looking for more information. Mae Brussell uncovered information that after World War II, many high ranking
Nazis waved a hankie at the oncoming American soldiers, gave over a bit of information, and were suddenly landing jobs within the FBI, the CIA, and other secret services. In these cases, they no longer became conspiracy theories, some became fact. Unfortunately, paranoia becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy, because both the JFK theorists and Mae Brussell began to believe everything they saw as suspicious, must be true. Something's not right, so everything must be wrong.
I guess what I'm trying to get at it the concept of belief in these theories. I had a good teacher, his name was
Robert Anton Wilson. Back in the seventies, he co-wrote a series called the '
Illuminatus Trilogy.' These days it's somewhat dated, but it still has it's moments of brilliance and you will find plenty of theories that will make you sit back and scratch your head. As soon as a passage like this occurs, you can be assured that the next passage will snap you back to reality and slap you in the face for wanting to believe it in the first place. Bob Wilson was a cut above such conspiracy theorists at the time, He took every story he heard with a grain of salt and a wry smile. In a sense, he made us understand why we loved conspiracy, because we love the line between fact and fiction. He was a champion of the excluded middle, and a model agnostic who used conspiracy theory to show people that absolute belief is a dangerous thing in all respects.
"All affirmations are true in some sense, false in some sense, meaningless in some sense, true and false in some sense, true and meaningless in some sense, false and meaningless in some sense, and true and false and meaningless in some sense..." He would quip.
Conspiracies
are real. At any time there are thousands of conspiracies occurring, all over the world. Most of them
blow up in a matter of years amid selfish human behavior and general pettiness. But conspiracies that deal with what happened in our past have no real bearing on our future, unfortunately. If you want to subscribe to Dan Brown's picture of the past, what you have is a worldview that is different, but in no way more interesting than what we have already. If you want to believe that there is a vast ongoing conspiracy, you're stuck with an unimaginative hold on life that is less than empowering. It's far too comforting to see some force guiding all of the bad events that occur before us. The world is far more frightening than an Illuminati dictating it's whims. The truth is, this world is utterly chaotic. Nobody is in control. We are rudderless.
In a post-9/11 reality, we now have so much information we don't know what to do with it. We are stuck with generations of people that are beginning to question everything and make up their own answers as they see fit. This is unfortunate because all that is needed is to... Simply... Question... Everything.